Automakers aren't usually receptive to the idea of us
driving their concept cars, as most of these are little more than million-dollar
auto-show paperweights that may not even move under their own power. The case of
the Dodge Circuit EV, however, is different. Lou Rhodes, president of Chrysler's
electric-car ENVI division, had no qualms about giving us the first chance to
wring the neck of this electric-powered sports car on a road course, the 1.7-mile
handling loop at the company's proving ground in Chelsea, Michigan.
Shown last fall for the first time, the Circuit is a not-sold-here Lotus
Europa (itself a slightly swollen version of the Elise) that's had its
powertrain replaced with a 268-hp, 295-lb-ft electric motor and a large,
35-kilowatt-hour lithium-ion battery pack. Comparisons with the Lotus
Elise based Tesla roadster are inevitable.
Engine Styling and Powertrain
When looking for a place to dock a 600-pound battery pack, a front-engine
platform is all wrong from the perspective of weight distribution. And finding a
mid-engine chassis from a manufacturer that will entertain inquiries for
low-volume orders quickly trims the options down to one: Lotus. Its lightweight
Elise and Exige S sports cars provide a tiny annual sales footprint in the U.S.
(less than 2000 units), but the company is set to expand with its larger, more
passenger-friendly Evora.
Versatility and Electric Powertrain Design
Rhodes touts the versatility of electric powertrains: A lower-power version
of the Circuit's motor can be shared with various other mainstream vehicles such
as the Chrysler Town & Country minivan and the Jeep Wrangler and Patriot; the
company has well-sorted running prototypes of each. While the Circuit is
battery-only, the other variants are of the range-extended electric variety, as
in Chevy's Volt, which is powered by an electric motor but has a gas engine
onboard to generate electricity if needed, which prevents occupants from being
marooned when the juice runs out.
Electric motors are very efficient (92 percent or so, compared with gasoline
engines, at 30 percent), and depending on the specifics of exactly how the EPA
will rate electric vehicles in the future, the Circuit will likely achieve an
energy-equivalent fuel-economy rating of well over 100 mpg.
Aside from cost, downsides include lack of energy storage (the massive
battery pack holds fewer kilowatt-hours than can be extracted from a single
gallon of gas) and, therefore, range. With just a claimed 150 miles between
time-consuming recharges 90 minutes to 12 hours, depending on the power
source the Circuit likely won't be your only car. So what does 295 pound-feet of
instant torque feel like in a 2650-pound sports car? Power oversteer is also
verboten at the moment, although we sincerely hope that a production version
would let the driver decide whether to melt the tires. As with our women, we
prefer that a powerful sports car be able to frighten us from time to time.
Electric Power and speed?
Whacking the power pedal once the car is up to speed, however, delivers a
realistic rendition of a gut-contorting sucker punch. The Circuit pulls strongly
well past 60 mph, but as triple digits approach, the lack of gears causes
acceleration to taper off far more dramatically than in a traditional sports
car. We're glad to report that electrics dilute the fun factor far less than
hybrids do. First off, battery regeneration while decelerating is dictated
solely by throttle position instead of brake application in the Dodge, so unlike
hybrids, brake-pedal feel remains firm and unpolluted. And the power delivery is
linear and predictable, unlike the annoying surging and high-rpm droning that
happens in CVT-equipped hybrids.
Test Drive Impressions
The only indication that the Circuit we drove wasn't quite production ready
was some light tire-to-fender rubbing during maximum-honk cornering situations.
Perhaps daydreams of the next generation will adapt to include the high-pitched
shriek of an electric motor up near its 13,500-rpm redline.
Officially, Chrysler says it is committed to electric vehicles and will launch a
single model next year. But the evidence overwhelmingly suggests that Chrysler
is planning to produce the Circuit. Rhodes let slip word of prototypes in
Michigan, Arizona, and the U.K. If Chrysler squeaks through its financial mess,
plan on living with the irony of this dainty, 100-mpg apex clipper following up
Dodge's other sports car, the brutish, politically incorrect Viper. Rhodes says
Chrysler is eventually planning to sell 100,000 electric vehicles per year
(spread over numerous platforms), which should drive down the cost of the
electric components such as the hugely expensive $25,000-plus battery pack and
enable the Circuit to be priced tens of thousands less than the $110,950 Tesla
sports car.
The way we see it, it doesn't much matter whether they're powered by
batteries or bee stings the more pure-driving Lotus-based vehicles inhabiting
our roads, the better. Start lobbying your local track now for a high-powered
charging source.
So how does it sound?
An EV sounds as thrilling as an electric toothbrush and roughly as powerful.
But Lotus is developing EVs and hybrid sound systems that can rattle eardrums
like a V-8 powered car, not chiefly for driving pleasure but for pedestrian
safety. With European and U.S. legislators considering minimum noise standards
for EVs, Lotus sees a potential market for its external electronic sound
synthesis technology.
The idea grew out of close calls at the Lotus facility in Hethel, England,
where workers were nearly clipped by Teslas. In a Toyota Prius demonstrator, a
waterproof, front-mounted speaker and amplifier draw from realistic engine
sounds (when in electric-only mode) that correspond to speed and throttle
position. When the Prius's gas engine fires up, the broadcast shuts down. To
trim noise pollution, sound is projected in a low, narrow field that's only
audible to people in the car's path.
Final Pre Production Impressions
Lotus testing revealed that EV prospects don't want a traditional stoplight
snarl but prefer a more futuristic note. We came up with this spaceship-y, Star
Trek warble, says Colin Peachey, Lotus's chief engineer for noise, vibration,
and harshness. Good engine sounds not only keep drivers involved and alert but
subdue tire drone, wind noise, and other annoying frequencies.
Lotus will roll out the technology on electric delivery vehicles for a U.K.
supermarket chain. It envisions applications ranging from filling in the sound
of a deactivated cylinder to making aftermarket devices for tuner-car fans.